Last checked

Brand coverage · Last reviewed

Magic Spoon allulose lawsuits

Verified cases, a dismissal, and dockets we are not counting yet

The short answer

  1. Five verified proposed class actions challenge “0g TOTAL SUGARS PER SERVING”, “0g Total Sugars”, “0g Added Sugar”, “No Added Sugar”, “FDA does not consider allulose a total or added sugar for nutrition labeling” claims on Magic Spoon Protein Cereal.
  2. Rules in play: 21 C.F.R. §§ 101.9, 101.13 (Total Sugars rules; Franco interpreted the Total Sugars definition); 21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(2) (the no-added-sugar rule, which Franco did not decide).
  3. Franco v. Chobani is binding in two of these cases (Seventh Circuit) and persuasive authority in the other three.
  4. No liability finding, class certification or court-approved settlement has been identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

Magic Spoon at a glance

Verified cases
5
Federal districts
3
Circuits
3
Classes certified*
None identified
Settlements*
None identified

Latest filing September 22, 2026. * In the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026; not a complete same-day docket review. Settlement status explained

On this page
  1. The Magic Spoon allulose cases we currently count
  2. Mirzaian and Kazemi: added from the complaints (November 2026)
  3. Freifeld: the "0 g Total Sugars" case
  4. Royal: a different claim theory
  5. Why the two verified Magic Spoon cases should not be collapsed
  6. What does Franco v. Chobani mean for Magic Spoon?
  7. Other Magic Spoon dockets exist, but we do not count them yet
  8. Why we use a research queue
  9. FDA guidance and Magic Spoon's Nutrition Facts issue
  10. Current procedural status
  11. Has a Magic Spoon class been certified?
  12. Is there a Magic Spoon allulose settlement?
  13. What we know and what we do not
  14. Frequently asked questions
  15. Sources

Magic Spoon is a useful example of why an allulose litigation tracker needs more than a list of search results.

Five Magic Spoon cases currently meet our standard for inclusion in our verified allulose counts:

  • Freifeld v. Magic Spoon, Inc., filed in the Northern District of Illinois on August 18, 2026;
  • Mirzaian v. Magic Spoon, Inc., filed in the Southern District of New York on August 19, 2026;
  • Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc., filed in the Northern District of California on August 31, 2026;
  • Royal v. Magic Spoon Inc., filed in the Northern District of Illinois on September 10, 2026; and
  • Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc., filed in the Southern District of New York on September 22, 2026.

They do not all challenge identical label language, and two have been voluntarily dismissed without prejudice. We added Mirzaian and both Kazemi dockets on November 10, 2026, after their complaints became free in the public court archive and we read them.

Other Magic Spoon dockets exist, but we have not promoted them into the verified allulose count because the allulose theory is not yet supported strongly enough under our source policy.

That distinction is the point of this page.

The rule in play

The federal rule treats “sugar free” and “no added sugar” claims under separate subsections. Claim families below come from our case record; they group reported allegations.

21 C.F.R. §§ 101.9, 101.13

0g Total Sugars

Addressed in Franco: Total Sugars rules. Franco v. Chobani interpreted the Total Sugars definition in § 101.9(c)(6)(ii).

21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(2)

Zero Added Sugar · No Added Sugar

Not decided in Franco: The no-added-sugar rule, § 101.60(c)(2). Franco v. Chobani addressed the sugar-free rule, not this one.

Franco v. Chobani held that allulose falls within the federal definition of sugar for the regulation it interpreted. It did not decide liability, and its binding effect is limited to the Seventh Circuit.

The Magic Spoon allulose cases we currently count

Filed after Franco

Verified Magic Spoon cases by filing date, July 27, 2026 to November 10, 2026. All five filed within 9 weeks of the ruling.

  1. Jul 27, 2026Franco v. Chobani: the Seventh Circuit reverses the dismissal
  2. Aug 18, 2026 · N.D. Ill.Freifeld v. Magic Spoon, Inc.Franco: binding
  3. Aug 19, 2026 · S.D.N.Y.Mirzaian v. Magic Spoon, Inc.Franco: persuasive
  4. Aug 31, 2026 · N.D. Cal.Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc.Franco: persuasive
  5. Sep 10, 2026 · N.D. Ill.Royal v. Magic Spoon Inc.Franco: binding
  6. Sep 22, 2026 · S.D.N.Y.Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc.Franco: persuasive
Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified cases only. Month-only filing dates are shown as a span across the month. Last checked November 10, 2026.

5 cases, newest filing first

Magic Spoon verified cases
FiledCaseWording challengedCourtFranco isLatest supported status
Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc.No. 1:26-cv-08238“0g TOTAL SUGARS PER SERVING”S.D.N.Y.PersuasiveComplaint filed
Royal v. Magic Spoon Inc.No. 1:26-cv-10993“0g Total Sugars”“0g Added Sugar”“No Added Sugar”N.D. Ill.BindingReported pending
Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc.No. 3:26-cv-09254“0g TOTAL SUGARS PER SERVING”N.D. Cal.PersuasiveVoluntarily dismissed
Mirzaian v. Magic Spoon, Inc.No. 1:26-cv-07075“0g TOTAL SUGARS PER SERVING”“FDA does not consider allulose a total or added sugar for nutrition labeling”S.D.N.Y.PersuasiveComplaint filed
Freifeld v. Magic Spoon, Inc.No. 1:26-cv-09944“0g Total Sugars”“0g Added Sugar”“No Added Sugar”N.D. Ill.BindingVoluntarily dismissed

Records reviewed through November 10, 2026. Verified totals include only supported core labeling cases. Sources and methodology.

CaseCourtFiledReported claimLatest supported status
Freifeld v. Magic Spoon, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-09944N.D. IllinoisAug. 18, 2026"0 g Total Sugars" / sugar-free theoryVoluntarily dismissed without prejudice Sept. 22, 2026
Royal v. Magic Spoon Inc., No. 1:26-cv-10993N.D. IllinoisSept. 10, 2026"0 added sugar" / "no added sugar"Reported pending in recent public coverage

The federal docket index confirms Freifeld was filed August 18, 2026 before Judge Steven C. Seeger. (Justia docket)

The federal docket index confirms Royal was filed September 10, 2026 before Judge Lindsay C. Jenkins. (Justia docket)

Mirzaian and Kazemi: added from the complaints (November 2026)

The Mirzaian complaint (S.D.N.Y., No. 1:26-cv-07075) alleges that 7-ounce Magic Spoon cereals say "0g TOTAL SUGARS PER SERVING" on the front while their side panels list between 5 and 10 grams of allulose per serving. It also challenges a label statement that the FDA does not consider allulose a total or added sugar for nutrition labeling. (Mirzaian complaint)

The Kazemi complaint makes a similar "0g TOTAL SUGARS PER SERVING" challenge for ten Magic Spoon cereals and pleads seven California claims. Maryam Kazemi first filed in the Northern District of California (No. 3:26-cv-09254), voluntarily dismissed that case without prejudice on September 22, 2026, and filed in the Southern District of New York the same day (No. 1:26-cv-08238). We list both dockets because both were filed, but they are one plaintiff's claim, not two separate groups of buyers. (Kazemi S.D.N.Y. complaint) (Kazemi N.D. Cal. docket)

In the Southern District of New York, Judge Colleen McMahon accepted the Magic Spoon cases there as related on October 19, 2026, and an amended complaint was filed in Mirzaian on October 22. Relating cases is not consolidation. These are allegations; no court has ruled on them.

Freifeld: the "0 g Total Sugars" case

Trade reporting describes Freifeld as challenging Magic Spoon cereal packaging that advertised "0 g total sugars" while the cereal was sweetened with allulose.

SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal reports that the complaint alleged 10 grams of allulose per serving and argued the zero-sugar message was deceptive. That report is secondary reporting about the complaint, not a judicial finding. (SupplySide Food & Beverage Journal)

The case was voluntarily dismissed without prejudice on September 22, 2026, according to the same report.

"Without prejudice" matters. It generally means the dismissal itself does not operate as a merits judgment barring a future filing of the same claim solely because of that dismissal.

The report speculates that an informal settlement is possible but says the lawyers and Magic Spoon did not explain why the case was dropped. We therefore do not classify the dismissal as a settlement.

Latest supported status

  • Freifeld v. Magic Spoon, Inc.

    Voluntarily dismissed without prejudice

    Recent secondary report. Checked October 3, 2026. This is the latest status supported by the public sources reviewed. It is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

Public docket indexes and secondary tracker reports do not establish the contents of the complete current court docket.

Sources for this module

Royal: a different claim theory

Royal reportedly challenges Magic Spoon Protein Cereal marketed as "0 added sugar" and "no added sugar" while containing allulose.

Law360's case index identifies the case as No. 1:26-cv-10993 in the Northern District of Illinois and describes a proposed class action alleging false labeling tied to allulose. (Law360 case index)

OpenClassActions likewise describes the case as an allulose labeling action involving "0 added sugar" and "no added sugar" claims, but notes that the complaint itself was not publicly available through the sources it reviewed. (OpenClassActions)

Because the complaint was not directly available in the primary-source set used for this page, we do not invent:

  • a complete flavor list;
  • the exact proposed class definition;
  • a complete cause-of-action list; or
  • an exact allulose quantity for every product at issue.

Those facts can be added when the underlying pleading is obtained.

Why the two verified Magic Spoon cases should not be collapsed

The cases illustrate two related but distinct regulatory theories.

Freifeld reportedly challenged "0 g Total Sugars" or sugar-free-style messaging.

Royal reportedly challenges "0 added sugar" and "no added sugar" wording.

That difference matters because federal rules distinguish between:

  • claims about the amount of sugar in the food; and
  • claims about whether sugar or sugar-containing ingredients were added during processing.

Section 101.60(c)(1) covers sugar-free and zero-sugar claims, while § 101.60(c)(2) addresses no-added-sugar wording and related conditions. (21 C.F.R. § 101.60)

A responsible tracker should store those as separate claim families rather than flattening both to "zero sugar."

Magic Spoon claims challenged

Verified Magic Spoon cases by claim family.

  1. 0g Total Sugars4
  2. Zero Added Sugar1
  3. No Added Sugar1
A case can challenge more than one claim. Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified and cross-checked cases only. Last checked November 10, 2026.
View as table
Magic Spoon claims challenged
GroupCases
0g Total Sugars4
Zero Added Sugar1
No Added Sugar1

What does Franco v. Chobani mean for Magic Spoon?

Freifeld and Royal were filed in the Northern District of Illinois. Mirzaian and the second Kazemi case are in the Southern District of New York, in the Second Circuit, where Franco is persuasive but not binding.

That places the Illinois cases inside the Seventh Circuit, whose July 27, 2026 Franco decision held that allulose falls within the federal regulatory definition of sugar relevant to the sugar-free issue before it. (Seventh Circuit opinion)

For a court in the Northern District of Illinois, that appellate holding is binding on the legal issue it decided.

But the claim-language distinction still matters.

Royal involves reported no-added-sugar wording, governed by a separate subsection from the sugar-free claim in Franco. So Franco is highly relevant to whether allulose is a sugar, but it does not automatically decide every element of Royal.

Other Magic Spoon dockets exist, but we do not count them yet

This is where our evidence model differs from a generic lawsuit roundup.

We are also researching other Magic Spoon dockets. Their existence is verified, but their connection to allulose has not yet met our threshold for counting them.

Examples include:

DocketWhat is verifiedWhy it is not in the allulose count
Freifeld v. Magic Spoon Inc., No. 1:26-cv-08281, S.D.N.Y.Case identity, filing, and a relatedness statementThe complaint still needs direct review before we count it as a separate allulose case
Trout v. Magic Spoon, Inc., No. 5:26-cv-00788, M.D. Fla.Case identity and filing (October 21, 2026)The complaint was not free when checked on November 10, 2026; the docket shows a transfer out on November 9 to a court not shown

The S.D.N.Y. Freifeld docket, for example, shows a complaint filed September 23, 2026 and a statement that it is related to No. 1:26-cv-07075. That proves the later case exists and is connected procedurally to another Magic Spoon case. It does not by itself prove that the complaint advances the allulose theory tracked here. (Justia docket)

Unresolved dockets: excluded from verified totals

Unresolved dockets: excluded from verified totals
Unresolved docketCourtDocketWhy it is not counted
Freifeld v. Magic Spoon Inc.S.D.N.Y.1:26-cv-08281Docket and statement of relatedness to 1:26-cv-07075 are verified. The complaint itself should be reviewed before counting this as a separate allulose case.
Trout v. Magic Spoon, Inc.M.D. Fla.5:26-cv-00788Case identity is verified from the court docket (filed 2026-10-21), but the complaint was not free when checked on November 10, 2026, so there is no evidence yet that it concerns allulose. Do not infer relevance from the defendant or from news reports alone.

Allulose relevance remains unverified for these entries. They are excluded from the verified case totals and have no individual case pages.

Sources for this module

Why we use a research queue

Without a research queue, it would be tempting to count every lawsuit against Magic Spoon filed in August or September as another allulose case.

That would inflate the dataset and could turn coincidence into a factual claim.

Our rule is stricter:

A docket enters the public allulose count only when reliable evidence connects that specific action to allulose and the challenged sugar-related representation.

That is why the headline number on this page may be lower than the number of Magic Spoon cases a broad web search can surface.

FDA guidance and Magic Spoon's Nutrition Facts issue

FDA's 2020 guidance allows manufacturers, through enforcement discretion, to exclude allulose from the amounts declared as Total Sugars and Added Sugars on the Nutrition Facts panel. (FDA guidance)

The current litigation asks whether front-of-package or other labeling claims communicate something that conflicts with the underlying nutrient-content rules.

That distinction is especially visible in Magic Spoon because the verified cases span both total-sugar and added-sugar language.

See Zero Sugar vs. Sugar Free vs. No Added Sugar for the claim-by-claim framework.

Current procedural status

Freifeld, N.D. Illinois

Supported status: voluntarily dismissed without prejudice on September 22, 2026, according to reporting on the filed notice.

That is a dismissal, not a court-approved settlement.

Royal, N.D. Illinois

Recent reporting describes the case as pending. The dataset does not represent that status as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

Magic Spoon: status in reviewed records

  • Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc.

    Complaint filed; no later outcome identified in reviewed sources

    Recent public court record. Checked November 10, 2026. The public docket was reviewed on November 10, 2026 and showed no ruling on the claims, certification or settlement. This is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

  • Royal v. Magic Spoon Inc.

    Pending, as reported in reviewed sources

    Recent secondary report. Checked October 3, 2026. This is the latest status supported by the public sources reviewed. It is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

  • Kazemi v. Magic Spoon Inc.

    Voluntarily dismissed without prejudice

    Recent public court record. Checked November 10, 2026. The docket shows a notice of voluntary dismissal (ECF 11) and the case terminated on September 22, 2026. The same plaintiff filed in the Southern District of New York that day.

  • Mirzaian v. Magic Spoon, Inc.

    Complaint filed; no later outcome identified in reviewed sources

    Recent public court record. Checked November 18, 2026. The public docket was reviewed on November 18, 2026. It shows the related-case order (October 19), an amended complaint (October 22), a motion to appoint counsel (November 9), a memo endorsement with questions from the judge (November 10) and a response in opposition to a motion (November 16). It shows no ruling on the claims, certification or settlement. This is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

  • Freifeld v. Magic Spoon, Inc.

    Voluntarily dismissed without prejudice

    Recent secondary report. Checked October 3, 2026. This is the latest status supported by the public sources reviewed. It is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

Public docket indexes and secondary tracker reports do not establish the contents of the complete current court docket.

Sources for this module

Has a Magic Spoon class been certified?

We have not identified a class-certification order in the verified Magic Spoon allulose records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

Is there a Magic Spoon allulose settlement?

We have not identified a court-approved settlement or claim form in the verified records reviewed.

The Freifeld voluntary dismissal should not be converted into a settlement merely because the reason for dismissal is not public.

What we know and what we do not

Supported

  • five Magic Spoon dockets are currently verified or cross-checked, two of them voluntarily dismissed without prejudice;
  • the Mirzaian and Kazemi complaints challenge "0g TOTAL SUGARS PER SERVING" claims and allege 5 to 10 grams of allulose per serving;
  • Freifeld involved reported "0 g Total Sugars" allegations;
  • Freifeld was voluntarily dismissed without prejudice on September 22;
  • Royal involves reported "0 added sugar" / "no added sugar" allegations;
  • other Magic Spoon federal dockets exist.

Not established

  • that every other Magic Spoon docket concerns allulose;
  • a complete public Royal complaint in the source set used for this page;
  • a final ruling on the merits in Royal;
  • a certified class;
  • a court-approved settlement;
  • a claim form;
  • that the Freifeld dismissal resulted from a settlement.

Frequently asked questions

How many Magic Spoon allulose lawsuits are you counting?

Our count includes only cases that meet our verification standard. Other Magic Spoon dockets stay out of the count until their connection to allulose is adequately supported.

Was the Magic Spoon lawsuit dismissed?

One verified Magic Spoon case, Freifeld v. Magic Spoon, Inc. in the Northern District of Illinois, was voluntarily dismissed without prejudice. A separate verified case, Royal v. Magic Spoon Inc., is distinct.

Does "dismissed without prejudice" mean Magic Spoon won?

Not necessarily. A voluntary dismissal without prejudice is not the same as a merits judgment for the defendant.

Is Royal controlled by Franco?

The Northern District of Illinois is within the Seventh Circuit, so Franco is binding on the regulatory issue it decided. Royal involves different reported claim wording, so additional issues remain.

Is there money available to claim?

We have not identified an official settlement or claim form in the records reviewed.

Sources cited in this guide (12)

Last researched: October 3, 2026; Mirzaian and Kazemi added November 10, 2026. Procedural status can change after this date.

Sources and further reading

Primary and court-derived sources are listed first. Secondary reporting is used for discovery and cross-checking.

Show all 16 sources

Bought Magic Spoon Protein Cereal?

Six short questions. See where your product stands first, then choose whether a law firm reviewing these claims can contact you.

Share your purchase Get updates only

About 2 minutes · No receipt needed · Sharing is your choice