Last checked

Brand coverage · Last reviewed

Lewis Bake Shop allulose lawsuit

The Better Way "0g Sugar" breads

The short answer

  1. One verified proposed class action challenges “0g Sugar” claims on Lewis Bake Shop Better Way breads.
  2. Rule in play: 21 C.F.R. §§ 101.13, 101.60(c)(1) (the sugar-free rule, which Franco addressed).
  3. None of these cases is in the Seventh Circuit, so Franco v. Chobani is persuasive authority only.
  4. No liability finding, class certification or court-approved settlement has been identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

Lewis Bake Shop at a glance

Verified cases
1
Federal districts
1
Circuits
1
Classes certified*
None identified
Settlements*
None identified

Latest filing November 13, 2026. * In the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026; not a complete same-day docket review. Settlement status explained

On this page
  1. The verified Lewis Bake Shop allulose case
  2. Which breads does the complaint name?
  3. What does the complaint allege about the label?
  4. What does the named plaintiff allege?
  5. The federal rule the complaint relies on
  6. How Franco v. Chobani fits
  7. The proposed classes and claims
  8. Current procedural status
  9. Has a class been certified? Is there a settlement?
  10. Other bread cases
  11. What we know and what we do not
  12. Frequently asked questions
  13. Sources

Watts v. Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc. is a proposed class action filed November 13, 2026 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York.

It challenges an unqualified "0g Sugar" statement on the front of five Lewis Bake Shop Better Way breads. According to the complaint, each bread lists allulose as an ingredient, and allulose is a sugar.

No class has been certified and no court has found Lewis Brothers Bakeries liable. We have not identified a settlement or claim form.

The rule in play

The federal rule treats “sugar free” and “no added sugar” claims under separate subsections. Claim families below come from our case record; they group reported allegations.

21 C.F.R. §§ 101.13, 101.60(c)(1)

0g Sugar

Addressed in Franco: The sugar-free rule, § 101.60(c)(1), which Franco v. Chobani addressed.

Franco v. Chobani held that allulose falls within the federal definition of sugar for the regulation it interpreted. It did not decide liability, and its binding effect is limited to the Seventh Circuit.

The verified Lewis Bake Shop allulose case

Filed after Franco

Verified Lewis Bake Shop cases by filing date, July 27, 2026 to November 10, 2026. Filed within 16 weeks of the ruling.

  1. Jul 27, 2026Franco v. Chobani: the Seventh Circuit reverses the dismissal
  2. Nov 13, 2026 · E.D.N.Y.Watts v. Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc.Franco: persuasive
Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified cases only. Month-only filing dates are shown as a span across the month. Last checked November 10, 2026.

1 case, newest filing first

Lewis Bake Shop verified cases
FiledCaseWording challengedCourtFranco isLatest supported status
Watts v. Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc.No. 1:26-cv-07348“0g Sugar”E.D.N.Y.PersuasiveComplaint filed

Records reviewed through November 10, 2026. Verified totals include only supported core labeling cases. Sources and methodology.

CaseCourtFiledDataset verification
Watts v. Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-07348E.D. New YorkNov. 13, 2026Primary complaint verified

The court docket confirms plaintiff Tiana Watts, defendant Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc., case No. 1:26-cv-07348 and the November 13 filing date. The case is assigned to Judge Diane Gujarati, with Magistrate Judge Seth D. Eichenholtz. (Watts court docket)

We read the complaint from the free copy in the court's RECAP archive. It is the source for the allegations on this page. (Watts complaint)

Which breads does the complaint name?

The complaint covers five Lewis Bake Shop Better Way breads:

  • Better Way 5 Seed Keto Bread (16 oz.);
  • Better Way Protein Bread (17.5 oz.);
  • Better Way Hawaiian Keto Bread (16 oz.), which the complaint says was formerly sold under the "Healthy Life" name;
  • Better Way White Keto Bread (16 oz.); and
  • Better Way Avocado & Seeds Keto Bread (16 oz.).

The complaint reserves the right to change that list as the case goes on. The case does not cover every Lewis Bake Shop product.

Lewis Bake Shop: product groups

  • Lewis Bake Shop Better Way breads

    Lewis Bake Shop · bread and baked goods

    “0g Sugar”

    1 verified case · filed Nov 13, 2026

Product groups summarize allegations in the reviewed cases. A listed product does not establish class membership, payment eligibility, or that every flavor or variant is challenged.

Sources for this module

What does the complaint allege about the label?

According to the complaint:

  • each bread's principal display panel carried the unqualified statement "0g SUGAR";
  • each bread's ingredient statement lists allulose;
  • allulose is the sixth-listed ingredient in the Protein Bread and the 5 Seed Keto Bread, and the fifth- or sixth-listed ingredient in the Hawaiian Keto Bread, depending on the packaging;
  • the back labels of the Hawaiian Keto Bread and the Protein Bread state "1g Allulose" per slice, which is the labeled serving; and
  • allulose is not followed by an asterisk or any statement that it adds only a trivial or insignificant amount of sugar.

The complaint argues that listing allulose among the ingredients does not cure the front-panel "0g SUGAR" statement, because a reasonable consumer would read that statement to mean the bread contains no sugar.

These are allegations. No court has found any of them to be true.

What does the named plaintiff allege?

According to the complaint, Tiana Watts, a Brooklyn resident, bought a 16-ounce Lewis Bake Shop Healthy Life Hawaiian Keto Bread at a Target store in Brooklyn on or about March 3, 2024. She alleges that she saw the "0g Sugar" statement before buying it and would not have bought it, or would have paid less, had she known it contained allulose.

That is the plaintiff's allegation about her own purchase.

The federal rule the complaint relies on

The theory rests on two federal regulations:

  • 21 C.F.R. § 101.9(c)(6)(ii), which defines total sugars as the sum of all free monosaccharides and disaccharides; and
  • 21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(1), which allows a "sugar free" type claim only when a food contains less than 0.5 grams of sugars per serving, among other conditions.

(21 C.F.R. § 101.9) (21 C.F.R. § 101.60)

The complaint argues that allulose, as a monosaccharide, counts toward that 0.5-gram limit. On that reading, breads with 1 gram of allulose per slice could not carry a zero-sugar claim.

FDA's 2020 guidance allows allulose to be left out of the Total Sugars and Added Sugars lines on the Nutrition Facts label. (FDA guidance) The complaint says that guidance concerns the Nutrition Facts panel and does not decide whether a separate front-panel "0g SUGAR" statement is misleading under New York law. That is the plaintiff's position. No court has ruled on it in this case.

How Franco v. Chobani fits

The complaint cites Franco v. Chobani, in which the Seventh Circuit held in July 2026 that allulose falls within the federal regulatory definition of sugar. (Seventh Circuit opinion)

Watts is in the Eastern District of New York, which is within the Second Circuit. So Franco is persuasive authority there, not binding precedent.

Lewis Bake Shop cases by circuit

Verified Lewis Bake Shop cases by federal circuit. The Seventh Circuit, where Franco binds, is shown in black.

  1. Second Circuit1
Franco is binding precedent for federal district courts in the Seventh Circuit and persuasive authority elsewhere. It does not decide every claim or establish liability. Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified and cross-checked cases only. Last checked November 10, 2026.
View as table
Lewis Bake Shop cases by circuit
GroupCases
Second Circuit1

The proposed classes and claims

The complaint proposes two classes:

  • a New York class of people who bought the breads in New York, in packaging bearing the "0g Sugar" statement, for personal, family or household use; and
  • a nationwide class of people in the United States who bought the breads in that packaging for the same purposes.

It pleads three claims:

  • New York General Business Law section 349, for the New York class;
  • New York General Business Law section 350, for the New York class; and
  • unjust enrichment, for the nationwide class or, alternatively, the New York class.

These are proposed classes and pleaded claims. No class has been certified, and no court has found that Lewis Brothers Bakeries violated any law.

Current procedural status

When we reviewed the docket on November 18, 2026, it showed the complaint, the judge assignment, the clerk's notice about consenting to a magistrate judge and the summons. It showed no ruling. (Watts court docket)

That is a public docket review, not a complete current PACER review.

Lewis Bake Shop: status in reviewed records

  • Watts v. Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc.

    Complaint filed; no later outcome identified in reviewed sources

    Recent public court record. Checked November 14, 2026. The public docket was reviewed on November 14, 2026, the day after filing, and showed no ruling on the claims, certification or settlement. This is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

Public docket indexes and secondary tracker reports do not establish the contents of the complete current court docket.

Sources for this module

Has a class been certified? Is there a settlement?

We have not identified a class-certification order, a court-approved settlement, a settlement administrator or a claim form in the records reviewed as of November 18, 2026.

The case is a newly filed proposed class action. A proposed class is not a certified class.

Other bread cases

Lewis Bake Shop is not the only bakery brand in allulose litigation. Hero Bread products face separate "0G SUGAR" lawsuits. See the Hero Bread allulose lawsuit guide. Those are different cases against a different company.

What we know and what we do not

Supported

  • one Lewis Bake Shop allulose case is in our count: Watts v. Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc. (E.D.N.Y.);
  • it was filed November 13, 2026;
  • it challenges "0g SUGAR" on five Better Way breads;
  • the complaint alleges each bread lists allulose as an ingredient;
  • New York and nationwide classes are proposed.

Not established

  • final liability;
  • a certified class;
  • a settlement or claim process;
  • that Lewis Bake Shop products outside the five named breads are part of the case;
  • a complete current PACER history.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a Lewis Bake Shop allulose lawsuit?

Yes. Watts v. Lewis Brothers Bakeries, Inc. challenges "0g Sugar" labels on five Lewis Bake Shop Better Way breads that, according to the complaint, contain allulose.

Which court is it in?

The U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, No. 1:26-cv-07348.

How much allulose does the complaint say is in the bread?

The complaint says the back labels of the Hawaiian Keto Bread and the Protein Bread state "1g Allulose" per slice. It does not give a figure for every bread.

Is it a nationwide class action?

A nationwide class is proposed, along with a New York class. Neither has been certified.

Is there a settlement?

We have not identified a court-approved settlement or claim process in the records reviewed.

Sources cited in this guide (6)

Last researched: November 18, 2026. Procedural status can change after this date.

Sources and further reading

Primary and court-derived sources are listed first. Secondary reporting is used for discovery and cross-checking.

Show all 6 sources

Bought Lewis Bake Shop Better Way breads?

Six short questions. See where your product stands first, then choose whether a law firm reviewing these claims can contact you.

Share your purchase Get updates only

About 2 minutes · No receipt needed · Sharing is your choice