Last checked

Brand coverage · Last reviewed

Liquid Death allulose lawsuits

The verified 0g Sugar cases and the case we are not counting yet

The short answer

  1. Four verified proposed class actions challenge “0g Sugar”, “Zero Sugar” claims on Liquid Death Sparkling Energy drinks.
  2. Rule in play: 21 C.F.R. §§ 101.13, 101.60(c)(1) (the sugar-free rule, which Franco addressed).
  3. None of these cases is in the Seventh Circuit, so Franco v. Chobani is persuasive authority only.
  4. No liability finding, class certification or court-approved settlement has been identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

Liquid Death at a glance

Verified cases
4
Federal districts
3
Circuits
2
Classes certified*
None identified
Settlements*
None identified

Latest filing September 14, 2026. * In the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026; not a complete same-day docket review. Settlement status explained

On this page
  1. The Liquid Death allulose cases we count
  2. What does the Williamson complaint allege?
  3. Which Liquid Death products are implicated?
  4. What claims do the complaints bring?
  5. Why Franco v. Chobani matters
  6. FDA guidance does not answer the whole front-label question
  7. A fifth Liquid Death case is not in our verified count
  8. How the four verified cases relate
  9. Current procedural status
  10. Has a Liquid Death class been certified?
  11. Is there a Liquid Death allulose settlement or claim form?
  12. What we know and what we do not
  13. Frequently asked questions
  14. Sources

Liquid Death's Sparkling Energy line is the subject of a cluster of proposed class actions alleging that "0g Sugar" and "Zero Sugar" claims are misleading because the drinks contain allulose.

We currently count four Liquid Death allulose cases as verified or cross-checked. A fifth case, Frelinghuysen v. Supplying Demand, Inc., has a confirmed federal docket, but its complaint is not publicly available, so its allulose theory is not verified and it is not in our count.

That split is important. The point of this page is not to produce the biggest possible lawsuit number. It is to show which dockets we can substantiate, what the complaints allege, and where the evidence remains thinner.

No court has made a final finding that Liquid Death or its corporate maker, Supplying Demand, Inc., violated the law in the cases tracked here.

The rule in play

The federal rule treats “sugar free” and “no added sugar” claims under separate subsections. Claim families below come from our case record; they group reported allegations.

21 C.F.R. §§ 101.13, 101.60(c)(1)

0g Sugar · Zero Sugar

Addressed in Franco: The sugar-free rule, § 101.60(c)(1), which Franco v. Chobani addressed.

Franco v. Chobani held that allulose falls within the federal definition of sugar for the regulation it interpreted. It did not decide liability, and its binding effect is limited to the Seventh Circuit.

The Liquid Death allulose cases we count

Filed after Franco

Verified Liquid Death cases by filing date, July 27, 2026 to November 10, 2026. All four filed within 7 weeks of the ruling.

  1. Jul 27, 2026Franco v. Chobani: the Seventh Circuit reverses the dismissal
  2. Aug 24, 2026 · N.D. Cal.Williamson v. Supplying Demand, Inc.Franco: persuasive
  3. Sep 4, 2026 · N.D. Cal.Loar et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc.Franco: persuasive
  4. Sep 10, 2026 · C.D. Cal.Truty et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc.Franco: persuasive
  5. Sep 14, 2026 · M.D. Fla.Mears v. Supplying Demand, Inc. d/b/a Liquid DeathFranco: persuasive
Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified cases only. Month-only filing dates are shown as a span across the month. Last checked November 10, 2026.

4 cases, newest filing first

Liquid Death verified cases
FiledCaseWording challengedCourtFranco isLatest supported status
Mears v. Supplying Demand, Inc. d/b/a Liquid DeathNo. 26-cv-2674“0g Sugar”“Zero Sugar”M.D. Fla.PersuasiveTransferred to another court
Truty et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc.No. 26-cv-10164“0g Sugar”“Zero Sugar”C.D. Cal.PersuasiveVoluntarily dismissed
Loar et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc.No. 26-cv-9703“0g Sugar”“Zero Sugar”N.D. Cal.PersuasiveReported pending
Williamson v. Supplying Demand, Inc.No. 4:26-cv-08839“0g Sugar”“Zero Sugar”N.D. Cal.PersuasiveComplaint filed

Records reviewed through November 10, 2026. Verified totals include only supported core labeling cases. Sources and methodology.

CaseCourtFiledVerification
Williamson v. Supplying Demand, Inc.N.D. CaliforniaAug. 24, 2026Primary complaint verified
Loar et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc., No. 3:26-cv-09703N.D. CaliforniaSept. 4, 2026Cross-checked
Truty et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc., No. 2:26-cv-10164C.D. CaliforniaSept. 10, 2026Cross-checked; voluntarily dismissed without prejudice Oct. 5, 2026
Mears v. Supplying Demand, Inc., No. 8:26-cv-02674M.D. FloridaSept. 14, 2026Primary complaint verified; transferred out of M.D. Florida Nov. 16, 2026 (receiving court not yet confirmed)

We have read the Williamson and Mears complaints. Federal docket indexes independently support the Loar and Truty filings. Truty has since ended: the plaintiff filed a notice of voluntary dismissal without prejudice on October 5, 2026. Mears has left the Middle District of Florida: after a motion to transfer (November 9) and an order on it (November 13), the docket shows a "District Transfer Out" entry on November 16, 2026. The free docket does not name the receiving court, and we have not yet found the receiving docket. (Truty court docket) (Loar docket) (Truty docket) (Mears court docket)

Williamson was filed in the Northern District of California on August 24, 2026. Public records display two divisional prefixes for the same docket. The complaint's caption page lists No. 4:26-cv-8839, CourtListener and Law360 display No. 4:26-cv-08839, and the court's header stamp on the filed complaint reads No. 3:26-cv-08839. These are one case, not two. (Williamson court docket) (Law360 case index)

What does the Williamson complaint allege?

Williamson is a 45-page proposed class action filed by James Williamson against Supplying Demand, Inc., the company behind Liquid Death. We read the complaint from the free copy in the court's RECAP archive. (Williamson complaint)

According to the complaint:

  • Liquid Death Sparkling Energy drinks are labeled "0g Sugar" on the front of every package and every can, and advertised online as "Zero Sugar";
  • allulose is the second-listed, and therefore the second most predominant, ingredient in the drinks;
  • allulose is a monosaccharide and therefore a sugar under 21 C.F.R. § 101.9(c)(6)(ii);
  • federal and California law allow a "sugar free" claim only when a food contains less than 0.5 grams of sugars per serving; and
  • consumers paid a price premium because of the zero-sugar representations.

These are allegations. No court has found any of them to be true.

Which Liquid Death products are implicated?

The Williamson complaint challenges Liquid Death 0g Sugar Sparkling Energy drinks. It lists four flavors, "including, but not limited to":

  • Murder Mystery;
  • Scary Strawberry;
  • Orange Horror; and
  • Tropical Terror.

It covers single 12-ounce cans, 12-packs and variety packs.

The Mears complaint names three of the same flavors (Scary Strawberry, Orange Horror and Tropical Terror) and uses Scary Strawberry as its representative product. (Mears complaint)

This page does not say that every Liquid Death product contains allulose or is part of the litigation. The cases we have read concern the Sparkling Energy line.

Liquid Death: product groups

  • Liquid Death Sparkling Energy drinks

    Liquid Death · energy beverage

    “0g Sugar” / “Zero Sugar”

    4 verified cases · filed Aug 24, 2026 to Sep 14, 2026

Product groups summarize allegations in the reviewed cases. A listed product does not establish class membership, payment eligibility, or that every flavor or variant is challenged.

Sources for this module

What claims do the complaints bring?

The Williamson complaint pleads five counts:

  • California's Unfair Competition Law;
  • California's False Advertising Law;
  • California's Consumers Legal Remedies Act;
  • breach of express warranty; and
  • unjust enrichment and restitution.

It proposes a nationwide class of purchasers and a California subclass. The three California statutory claims are brought for the California subclass; the warranty and unjust enrichment claims are brought for the nationwide class and the subclass.

The Mears complaint, filed by Keri Mears in the Middle District of Florida, pleads claims under Florida's Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act and Florida's false-advertising statute (§ 817.41, Fla. Stat.) for a proposed Florida class, and an unjust enrichment claim for a proposed national class.

Those are pleaded causes of action, not judicial findings. No court has certified any of these proposed classes in the records we reviewed.

Why Franco v. Chobani matters

The legal theory closely follows the issue the Seventh Circuit addressed in Franco v. Chobani.

On July 27, 2026, the Seventh Circuit held that allulose falls within the federal regulatory definition of sugar because it is a monosaccharide. The court also held that the plaintiffs had plausibly alleged deception from an absolute zero-sugar representation and reversed the district court dismissal. (Seventh Circuit opinion)

Williamson was filed less than a month later.

That timing does not prove that Franco caused the filing. What can be said is that the Williamson complaint relies on the same regulatory framework and cites the Seventh Circuit's decision directly.

The verified Liquid Death cases are spread across the Ninth and Eleventh Circuits, not the Seventh.

That means Franco is persuasive authority in those courts, not binding Seventh Circuit precedent.

Liquid Death cases by circuit

Verified Liquid Death cases by federal circuit. The Seventh Circuit, where Franco binds, is shown in black.

  1. Ninth Circuit3
  2. Eleventh Circuit1
Franco is binding precedent for federal district courts in the Seventh Circuit and persuasive authority elsewhere. It does not decide every claim or establish liability. Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified and cross-checked cases only. Last checked November 10, 2026.
View as table
Liquid Death cases by circuit
GroupCases
Ninth Circuit3
Eleventh Circuit1

FDA guidance does not answer the whole front-label question

FDA's October 2020 allulose guidance says the agency intends to exercise enforcement discretion allowing allulose to be excluded from Total Sugars and Added Sugars declarations on the Nutrition Facts panel. (FDA guidance)

The current lawsuits focus on a different labeling question: whether a prominent "0g Sugar," "Zero Sugar," or equivalent nutrient-content claim complies with the regulations governing those representations.

Section 101.9 defines Total Sugars. Section 101.60(c)(1) governs sugar-free, no-sugar, and zero-sugar claims. (21 C.F.R. § 101.9) (21 C.F.R. § 101.60)

That distinction between Nutrition Facts treatment and front-of-package messaging is the same structural issue that runs through much of the allulose litigation wave.

A fifth Liquid Death case is not in our verified count

Frelinghuysen v. Supplying Demand, Inc. was filed by John Frelinghuysen in the Southern District of New York on August 25, 2026 (No. 1:26-cv-07275). By stipulation, it moved to the Northern District of California under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a), where it is No. 4:26-cv-11987. On October 30, 2026, Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley ordered it related to Williamson. (Frelinghuysen S.D.N.Y. docket) (Frelinghuysen N.D. Cal. docket) (Williamson docket)

Its case identity is confirmed from those court dockets. We list it as reported but not verified because its complaint is not publicly available, so its allulose theory is not confirmed from a court record.

When we reviewed it on October 4, 2026, Truth in Advertising's tracker listed the case, spelled "Frehlinghuysen," alongside Loar, Mears and Truty. It described the allegation as falsely marketing Sparkling Energy drinks as containing zero sugar when they contain allulose. (Truth in Advertising) The court dockets spell the plaintiff's name Frelinghuysen, and we follow the court record.

That tracker page did not list Williamson. Williamson is supported by its own complaint and docket, so we count it.

So we:

  • count the four verified records;
  • list Frelinghuysen separately as a docketed case whose allulose theory is not yet verified; and
  • will add it to our count only if its complaint or another court record confirms the allulose theory.

Reported but not verified: excluded from verified totals

Reported but not verified: excluded from verified totals
Reported caseCourtDocketFiled
Frelinghuysen v. Supplying Demand, Inc.N.D. Cal.4:26-cv-11987Aug 25, 2026

These records are supported only by secondary reporting. They are excluded from verified totals and have no individual case pages until court-derived sources confirm them.

Sources for this module

How the four verified cases relate

The four verified records are separate federal dockets.

Two were filed in the Northern District of California, one in the Central District of California, and one in the Middle District of Florida.

The shared defendant and similar claim theory do not by themselves establish consolidation, coordination, or a single national proceeding.

On September 30, 2026, Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley ordered Loar related to Williamson, and on October 30 she did the same for Frelinghuysen after its transfer from New York. Relating cases places them before one judge. It is not consolidation. (Williamson court docket)

Unless a court orders otherwise, we treat each as its own lawsuit.

That is particularly important for class definitions, causes of action, and procedural status. Facts attributed to Williamson should not automatically be copied into Loar, Truty, or Mears.

Current procedural status

Based on the public dockets we reviewed in November 2026:

  • Williamson: pending in the Northern District of California. The docket through November 5, 2026 shows the two relating orders and no ruling on the claims.
  • Loar: related to Williamson on September 30, 2026. We have not separately reviewed the Loar docket since then.
  • Truty: voluntarily dismissed without prejudice on October 5, 2026.
  • Mears: transferred out of the Middle District of Florida on November 16, 2026. The receiving court is not yet confirmed.
  • Frelinghuysen (not counted): transferred from New York to the Northern District of California and related to Williamson.

These are public docket reviews, not a complete current PACER review. They do not rule out later filings that the free dockets do not show.

Liquid Death: status in reviewed records

  • Mears v. Supplying Demand, Inc. d/b/a Liquid Death

    Transferred to another federal district; receiving court not yet confirmed

    Recent public court record. Checked November 18, 2026. The Middle District of Florida docket was reviewed on November 18, 2026. It shows a motion to transfer (ECF 7), an order on it entered November 13, 2026 and a "District Transfer Out" entry on November 16, 2026. The receiving court is not shown. No ruling on the claims, certification or settlement appears. This is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

  • Truty et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc.

    Voluntarily dismissed without prejudice

    Recent public court record. Checked November 10, 2026. The docket shows a notice of voluntary dismissal without prejudice on October 5, 2026 and no later entries. A dismissal without prejudice does not decide the claims.

  • Loar et al. v. Supplying Demand, Inc.

    Pending, as reported by a secondary tracker

    Recent secondary tracker report. Checked October 3, 2026. A current secondary tracker reports the case pending. This is not a substitute for a complete same-day PACER docket.

  • Williamson v. Supplying Demand, Inc.

    Complaint filed; current status not confirmed in reviewed sources

    Case sources only; status source under review. Checked October 4, 2026. The tracker the dataset cites for this case’s status did not list the case when rechecked on October 4, 2026, so we do not rely on it. The filing itself is supported by Law360 and complaint-based reporting.

Public docket indexes and secondary tracker reports do not establish the contents of the complete current court docket.

Sources for this module

Has a Liquid Death class been certified?

We have not identified a class-certification order in the records reviewed as of November 18, 2026.

The lawsuits are proposed class actions. Proposed classes are not certified classes.

Is there a Liquid Death allulose settlement or claim form?

We have not identified a court-approved settlement, official settlement administrator, or court-authorized claim form for the Liquid Death allulose cases in the records reviewed as of November 18, 2026.

That does not mean we have performed a complete live PACER sweep of every docket.

What we know and what we do not

Supported by the reviewed sources

  • four Liquid Death allulose cases currently are verified or cross-checked;
  • the verified litigation concerns Liquid Death Sparkling Energy;
  • Williamson challenges "0g Sugar" and "Zero Sugar" representations;
  • the Williamson complaint alleges that allulose is the second-listed ingredient in the challenged drinks;
  • Williamson proposes a nationwide class and a California subclass, and Mears proposes a national class and a Florida class;
  • the cases span federal courts in California and Florida;
  • Truty was voluntarily dismissed without prejudice on October 5, 2026;
  • Mears was transferred out of the Middle District of Florida on November 16, 2026;
  • a fifth Liquid Death matter, Frelinghuysen, has a confirmed docket in the Northern District of California and is related to Williamson, but its allulose theory is not yet verified.

Not established by the reviewed sources

  • final liability;
  • a certified nationwide Liquid Death class;
  • a court-approved settlement;
  • a payment amount;
  • that the four verified cases have been consolidated;
  • that every Liquid Death lawsuit concerns allulose;
  • a complete current PACER status for every docket;
  • the court that received Mears after its transfer;
  • a definitive resolution of the public divisional-prefix discrepancy for the Williamson docket.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a Liquid Death lawsuit over allulose?

Yes. We track a cluster of proposed federal class actions challenging zero-sugar claims on Liquid Death Sparkling Energy drinks containing allulose.

How many Liquid Death allulose cases are verified?

As of our November 18 review, four Liquid Death cases are verified or cross-checked, and one of them (Truty) has been voluntarily dismissed without prejudice. Frelinghuysen has a confirmed docket but an unconfirmed allulose theory, so it is not in our count.

Which drinks are involved?

The Williamson complaint identifies Liquid Death 0g Sugar Sparkling Energy, including Murder Mystery, Scary Strawberry, Orange Horror, and Tropical Terror.

Did a court decide Liquid Death's "0g Sugar" claim is illegal?

No. The sources reviewed establish allegations and filings, not a final merits ruling against Liquid Death.

Can buyers submit a settlement claim?

We have not identified an official settlement claim process in the records reviewed.

Sources cited in this guide (14)

Last researched: October 4, 2026; updated November 18, 2026. Procedural status can change after this date.

Sources and further reading

Primary and court-derived sources are listed first. Secondary reporting is used for discovery and cross-checking.

Show all 19 sources

Bought Liquid Death Sparkling Energy drinks?

Six short questions. See where your product stands first, then choose whether a law firm reviewing these claims can contact you.

Share your purchase Get updates only

About 2 minutes · No receipt needed · Sharing is your choice