Brand coverage · Last reviewed
Monin allulose lawsuits
17 Sugar Free products, a California case and an Illinois case
The short answer
- Two verified proposed class actions challenge “Sugar Free”, “Zero Sugar” claims on Monin Sugar Free syrups and sweetener.
- Rule in play: 21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(1) (the sugar-free rule, which Franco addressed).
- Franco v. Chobani is binding in one of these cases (Seventh Circuit) and persuasive authority in the other.
- No liability finding, class certification or court-approved settlement has been identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.
Monin at a glance
- Verified cases
- 2
- Federal districts
- 2
- Circuits
- 2
- Classes certified*
- None identified
- Settlements*
- None identified
Latest filing September 15, 2026. * In the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026; not a complete same-day docket review. Settlement status explained
On this page
- The verified Monin allulose cases
- Which 17 Monin products does the lawsuit identify?
- What does the complaint allegedly say about the label?
- The Sugar Free rule has two components
- Why the Nutrition Facts panel does not end the case
- How Franco v. Chobani fits
- Stanton v. Monin: the Illinois case (added November 2026)
- The De La Paz proposed classes are limited to California
- What legal claims are reported?
- What purchase does the named plaintiff allege?
- Current procedural status
- Has a Monin class been certified?
- Is there a Monin allulose settlement or claim form?
- What we know and what we do not
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
The Monin allulose case is unusually specific about product scope.
De La Paz v. Monin, Inc., filed September 8, 2026 in the Central District of California, challenges 17 Monin products marketed as "Sugar Free" while allegedly containing allulose.
The reviewed complaint-based sources describe 16 syrups plus Monin Sugar Free Sweetener. The lawsuit argues that allulose is a monosaccharide included within the federal definition of sugar and that the challenged products therefore do not meet the conditions for a "Sugar Free" nutrient-content claim.
A second case, Stanton v. Monin, Inc., filed September 15, 2026 in the Northern District of Illinois, challenges the same Sugar Free line. We added it on November 10, 2026 after reading its complaint (see below).
No class has been certified and no court has found Monin liable.
The rule in play
The federal rule treats “sugar free” and “no added sugar” claims under separate subsections. Claim families below come from our case record; they group reported allegations.
21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(1)
Sugar Free · Zero Sugar
Addressed in Franco: The sugar-free rule, § 101.60(c)(1), which Franco v. Chobani addressed.
Franco v. Chobani held that allulose falls within the federal definition of sugar for the regulation it interpreted. It did not decide liability, and its binding effect is limited to the Seventh Circuit.
The verified Monin allulose cases
Filed after Franco
Verified Monin cases by filing date, July 27, 2026 to November 10, 2026. All two filed within 8 weeks of the ruling.
- Jul 27, 2026Franco v. Chobani: the Seventh Circuit reverses the dismissal
- Sep 8, 2026 · C.D. Cal.De La Paz v. Monin, Inc.
- Sep 15, 2026 · N.D. Ill.Stanton v. Monin, Inc.
2 cases, newest filing first
| Filed | Case | Wording challenged | Court | Franco is | Latest supported status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stanton v. Monin, Inc.No. 1:26-cv-11319 | “Sugar Free”“Zero Sugar” | N.D. Ill. | Binding | Complaint filed | |
| De La Paz v. Monin, Inc.No. 2:26-cv-10024 | “Sugar Free” | C.D. Cal. | Persuasive | Reported pending |
No cases match these filters. If you bought a product that isn’t here, you can still share your purchase.
Open the Monin cases in the case tracker
Records reviewed through November 10, 2026. Verified totals include only supported core labeling cases. Sources and methodology.
| Case | Court | Filed | Dataset verification |
|---|---|---|---|
| De La Paz v. Monin, Inc., No. 2:26-cv-10024 | C.D. California | Sept. 8, 2026 | Cross-checked |
| Stanton v. Monin, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-11319 | N.D. Illinois | Sept. 15, 2026 | Primary complaint verified |
The federal docket index confirms plaintiff Henry De La Paz, defendant Monin, Inc., the September 8 filing date, and case No. 2:26-cv-10024. The docket snapshot shows the complaint and opening papers filed that day. (Justia docket)
A public court-feed archive later shows an initial order on September 22, 2026. That is useful evidence of post-filing activity but still does not represent the entire current docket. (Open Public Records)
Which 17 Monin products does the lawsuit identify?
Complaint-based reporting identifies these products:
Classic flavors
- Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup;
- Sugar Free French Vanilla Syrup;
- Sugar Free Caramel Syrup;
- Sugar Free Chocolate Syrup; and
- Sugar Free White Chocolate Syrup.
Fruit flavors
- Sugar Free Raspberry Syrup;
- Sugar Free Blue Raspberry Syrup;
- Sugar Free Blackberry Syrup;
- Sugar Free Strawberry Syrup;
- Sugar Free Peach Syrup;
- Sugar Free Mango Syrup;
- Sugar Free Pomegranate Syrup; and
- Sugar Free Coconut Syrup.
Other flavors
- Sugar Free Lavender Syrup;
- Sugar Free Almond (Orgeat) Syrup; and
- Sugar Free Triple Sec Syrup.
Sweetener
- Monin Sugar Free Sweetener.
The lawsuit does not purport to challenge every Monin product. Products outside the Sugar Free line should not be swept into the page merely because they share the Monin brand.
Monin: product groups
Monin Sugar Free syrups and sweetener
“Sugar Free” / “Zero Sugar”
Product groups summarize allegations in the reviewed cases. A listed product does not establish class membership, payment eligibility, or that every flavor or variant is challenged.
Sources for this module
- Stanton v. Monin, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-11319 (docket) (Court-derived docket index)
- Stanton v. Monin, Inc. Class Action Complaint (Primary source)
- Stanton v. Monin, Inc. (Court-derived docket index)
- Monin Sugar Free Syrup Lawsuit Over Allulose Sweetener (Secondary source)
- De La Paz v. Monin, Inc. (Court-derived docket index)
What does the complaint allegedly say about the label?
The complaint-based sources say "Sugar Free" appears multiple times on the front label of the challenged products.
They also report that allulose appears in the ingredient lists.
The plaintiff's theory is that a front-panel promise that a food is "Sugar Free" must comply with the federal nutrient-content rule even if FDA permits different treatment of allulose within the Nutrition Facts panel. (OpenClassActions)
Unlike some other allulose complaints, the public summaries reviewed do not establish a single exact allulose grams-per-serving figure for all 17 Monin products.
The complaint is reported to allege, on information and belief, that the products exceed the sugar-free threshold once allulose is counted.
We keep that distinction instead of inventing a number.
The Sugar Free rule has two components
The Monin theory focuses on 21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(1).
Complaint-based reporting emphasizes two parts of that rule:
- a quantitative condition requiring less than 0.5 grams of sugars per serving, using the regulatory definition of sugars; and
- an ingredient-disclosure condition that can require an asterisk and a statement such as "adds a trivial amount of sugar" in specified circumstances.
The Monin complaint reportedly alleges that the products fail both.
It says the allulose should count toward the sugar threshold and that allulose appears in the ingredient list without the relevant asterisk-and-footnote treatment. (OpenClassActions)
Those remain allegations. No court has ruled that the Monin labels violate § 101.60.
Why the Nutrition Facts panel does not end the case
FDA's 2020 guidance allows allulose to be excluded from Total Sugars and Added Sugars declarations on the Nutrition Facts label through enforcement discretion. (FDA guidance)
The Monin lawsuit treats that as different from a front-label "Sugar Free" nutrient-content claim.
That difference is the recurring structural issue across the current litigation wave.
Section 101.9 defines sugars. Section 101.60 governs sugar-content claims. A manufacturer's Nutrition Facts treatment under FDA guidance does not automatically answer whether a separate "Sugar Free" claim satisfies § 101.60. (21 C.F.R. § 101.9) (21 C.F.R. § 101.60)
How Franco v. Chobani fits
The Monin case was filed after the Seventh Circuit's decision in Franco v. Chobani.
In Franco, the court held that allulose falls within the federal regulatory definition of sugar because it is a monosaccharide. The court also treated FDA's allulose guidance as enforcement policy rather than a regulatory amendment. (Seventh Circuit opinion)
But Monin's case is in the Central District of California, within the Ninth Circuit.
So Franco is persuasive authority there, not binding precedent.
Stanton v. Monin: the Illinois case (added November 2026)
Stanton v. Monin, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-11319 (N.D. Ill.), was on our research list until its complaint became free in the public court archive. We read it on November 10, 2026. According to the complaint, 16 Monin Sugar Free syrups and Monin Sugar Free Sweetener are marketed as "Sugar Free" and "Zero Sugar," with 0g sugar on the Nutrition Facts panel, while allulose is one of their principal ingredients. It pleads the Illinois Consumer Fraud and Deceptive Business Practices Act, multi-state consumer fraud statutes and unjust enrichment, and proposes Illinois and multi-state classes. The case is before Judge Matthew F. Kennelly. These are allegations; no court has ruled on them. (Stanton complaint) (Stanton docket)
Because Stanton is in the Seventh Circuit, the Franco v. Chobani holding on whether allulose is a sugar binds the court there on that question.
The De La Paz proposed classes are limited to California
This is one of the most important practical differences between De La Paz and several other allulose cases.
Complaint-based reporting says the De La Paz complaint proposes:
- a California class of state residents who bought the challenged products within the limitations period; and
- a California consumer subclass for purchases made for personal, family, or household use.
It does not propose a nationwide class in the complaint as reported. (OpenClassActions)
That means a purchaser in another state is not within these proposed class definitions as they are currently described.
No class has been certified.
What legal claims are reported?
The complaint is reported to plead seven California-law counts:
- Consumers Legal Remedies Act;
- False Advertising Law;
- Unfair Competition Law;
- breach of express warranty;
- breach of the implied warranty of merchantability;
- unjust enrichment; and
- common-law fraud.
The case uses California's Sherman Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Law as the state-law route for incorporating federal food-labeling standards. (OpenClassActions)
Again, those are pleaded theories, not findings that Monin violated those laws.
What purchase does the named plaintiff allege?
Complaint-based reporting says Henry De La Paz bought Monin Sugar Free French Vanilla Syrup online in or around July 2024 while living in California.
The reported theory is that he relied on the Sugar Free representation and would not have bought the product on the same terms had he known it contained allulose.
That is the plaintiff's allegation of reliance and economic injury.
Current procedural status
The initial federal docket snapshot shows only opening filings on September 8.
A later public court feed reports an initial order on September 22.
That demonstrates post-filing activity but not a complete current docket.
OpenClassActions describes the matter as early-stage and had not identified a substantive response from Monin when it reported on the case. (OpenClassActions)
Monin: status in reviewed records
Complaint filed; no later outcome identified in reviewed sources
Recent public court record. Checked November 10, 2026. The public docket was reviewed on November 10, 2026 and showed no ruling on the claims, certification or settlement. This is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.
Pending, as reported in reviewed sources
Recent secondary report. Checked October 3, 2026. This is the latest status supported by the public sources reviewed. It is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.
Public docket indexes and secondary tracker reports do not establish the contents of the complete current court docket.
Sources for this module
- Stanton v. Monin, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-11319 (docket) (Court-derived docket index)
- Monin Sugar Free Syrup Lawsuit Over Allulose Sweetener (Secondary source)
Has a Monin class been certified?
We have not identified a class-certification order in the records reviewed as of October 4, 2026.
Is there a Monin allulose settlement or claim form?
We have not identified a court-approved settlement, settlement fund, administrator, or claim form in the records reviewed as of October 4, 2026.
What we know and what we do not
Supported
- two Monin allulose cases are verified or cross-checked: De La Paz v. Monin, Inc. (C.D. Cal.) and Stanton v. Monin, Inc. (N.D. Ill.);
- the reviewed complaint-based sources identify 17 Sugar Free products;
- the De La Paz classes are California-only as currently reported, while Stanton proposes Illinois and multi-state classes;
- the legal theory focuses on § 101.60(c)(1);
- seven California-law causes of action are reported.
Not established
- final liability;
- a certified class;
- a settlement;
- an exact allulose amount for each of the 17 products;
- that non-Sugar-Free Monin products are part of the case;
- a complete current PACER history.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a Monin allulose lawsuit?
Yes. De La Paz v. Monin, Inc. (California) and Stanton v. Monin, Inc. (Illinois) challenge Sugar Free labeling on Monin products that allegedly contain allulose.
Is it a nationwide class action?
No. De La Paz proposes California classes only. Stanton proposes an Illinois class and a multi-state class covering buyers in eight states. Neither class has been certified.
Which Monin product did the named plaintiff buy?
Complaint-based reporting says he bought Sugar Free French Vanilla Syrup.
Is there a settlement?
We have not identified a court-approved settlement or claim process in the records reviewed.
Sources cited in this guide (8)
Last researched: October 4, 2026; Stanton added November 10, 2026. Procedural status can change after this date.
Sources and further reading
Primary and court-derived sources are listed first. Secondary reporting is used for discovery and cross-checking.
Show all 10 sources
- Stanton v. Monin, Inc. Class Action ComplaintPrimary source · U.S. District Court filing, free RECAP copy hosted by CourtListener · Sep 15, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 10, 2026
- Franco v. Chobani, LLC, No. 25-2087Primary source · U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit / Justia mirror · Jul 27, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 3, 2026
- Guidance for Industry: Declaration of Allulose and Calories from Allulose on Nutrition and Supplement Facts LabelsPrimary source · U.S. Food and Drug Administration · October 2020 · Reviewed Oct 3, 2026
- 21 C.F.R. § 101.9Primary source · Electronic Code of Federal Regulations · Reviewed Oct 3, 2026
- 21 C.F.R. § 101.60Primary source · Electronic Code of Federal Regulations · Reviewed Oct 3, 2026
- De La Paz v. Monin, Inc.Court-derived docket index · Justia Dockets · Reviewed Oct 3, 2026
- Stanton v. Monin, Inc., No. 1:26-cv-11319 (docket)Court-derived docket index · CourtListener (RECAP docket mirrored from PACER) · Sep 15, 2026 · Reviewed Nov 10, 2026
- De La Paz v. Monin Inc public court feedPublic court-feed archive · Open Public Records · Reviewed Oct 4, 2026
- Monin Sugar Free Syrup Lawsuit Over Allulose SweetenerSecondary source · OpenClassActions · Reviewed Oct 3, 2026
- Monin Sugar Free Syrup Lawsuit: 17 Products, CaliforniaSecondary source · OpenClassActions · Oct 1, 2026 · Reviewed Oct 4, 2026