Last checked

Brand coverage · Last reviewed

Welch's allulose lawsuits

The short answer

  1. Six verified proposed class actions challenge “Zero Sugar”, “ZERO SUGAR” claims on Welch's Fruity Bites.
  2. Rule in play: 21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(1) (the sugar-free rule, which Franco addressed).
  3. Franco v. Chobani is binding in one of these cases (Seventh Circuit) and persuasive authority in the other five.
  4. No liability finding, class certification or court-approved settlement has been identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

Welch's at a glance

Verified cases
6
Federal districts
5
Circuits
3
Classes certified*
None identified
Settlements*
None identified

Latest filing September 25, 2026. * In the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026; not a complete same-day docket review. Settlement status explained

This page is built from the structured case record. A full editorial guide to the Welch's cases has not been published yet. Allegations are not findings of fact.

On this page
  1. The cases
  2. The rule in play
  3. Products
  4. Where the cases stand
  5. Where Franco binds
  6. Background reading
  7. Sources

The Welch's cases we track

Filed after Franco

Verified Welch's cases by filing date, July 27, 2026 to November 10, 2026. All six filed within 9 weeks of the ruling.

  1. Jul 27, 2026Franco v. Chobani: the Seventh Circuit reverses the dismissal
  2. September 2026 (day not verified) · E.D.N.Y.Feliciano et al. v. Promotion In Motion, Inc.Franco: persuasive
  3. September 2026 (day not verified) · E.D.N.Y.Ross et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc.Franco: persuasive
  4. Sep 11, 2026 · S.D. Cal.Maghoney et al. v. Promotion in Motion, Inc. and Welch Foods Inc.Franco: persuasive
  5. Sep 14, 2026 · D. Or.Gavros et al. v. P.I.M. Brands USA, Inc.Franco: persuasive
  6. Sep 15, 2026 · N.D. Ill.Santoyo et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc.Franco: binding
  7. Sep 25, 2026 · C.D. Cal.Amer et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc. and Welch Foods Inc.Franco: persuasive
Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified cases only. Month-only filing dates are shown as a span across the month. Last checked November 10, 2026.

6 cases, newest filing first

Welch's verified cases
FiledCaseWording challengedCourtFranco isLatest supported status
Amer et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc. and Welch Foods Inc.No. 26-cv-2822“Zero Sugar”C.D. Cal.PersuasiveStayed pending JPML decision
Santoyo et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc.No. 1:26-cv-11316“Zero Sugar”N.D. Ill.BindingReported pending
Gavros et al. v. P.I.M. Brands USA, Inc.No. 3:26-cv-01908“ZERO SUGAR”D. Or.PersuasiveComplaint filed
Maghoney et al. v. Promotion in Motion, Inc. and Welch Foods Inc.No. 3:26-cv-05235“Zero Sugar”S.D. Cal.PersuasiveReported pending
Feliciano et al. v. Promotion In Motion, Inc.No. 1:26-cv-05405“Zero Sugar”E.D.N.Y.PersuasiveReported pending
Ross et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc.No. 2:26-cv-05551“Zero Sugar”E.D.N.Y.PersuasiveReported pending

Records reviewed through November 10, 2026. Verified totals include only supported core labeling cases. Sources and methodology.

The rule in play

The federal rule treats “sugar free” and “no added sugar” claims under separate subsections. Claim families below come from our case record; they group reported allegations.

21 C.F.R. § 101.60(c)(1)

Zero Sugar

Addressed in Franco: The sugar-free rule, § 101.60(c)(1), which Franco v. Chobani addressed.

Franco v. Chobani held that allulose falls within the federal definition of sugar for the regulation it interpreted. It did not decide liability, and its binding effect is limited to the Seventh Circuit.

Welch's: product groups

  • Welch's Fruity Bites

    Welch's · candy / fruit snack

    “Zero Sugar” / “ZERO SUGAR”

    6 verified cases · filed September 2026 to Sep 25, 2026

Product groups summarize allegations in the reviewed cases. A listed product does not establish class membership, payment eligibility, or that every flavor or variant is challenged.

Sources for this module

Welch's: status in reviewed records

  • Amer et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc. and Welch Foods Inc.

    Stayed while the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation decides a transfer motion

    Recent public court record. Checked October 15, 2026. The court stayed the case on October 13, 2026 pending the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation's decision on the defendants' transfer motion. Which other actions the motion covers has not been verified here, and no multidistrict litigation has been created.

  • Santoyo et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc.

    Pending, as reported by a secondary tracker

    Recent secondary tracker report. Checked October 3, 2026. A current secondary tracker reports the case pending. This is not a substitute for a complete same-day PACER docket.

  • Gavros et al. v. P.I.M. Brands USA, Inc.

    Complaint filed; no later outcome identified in reviewed sources

    Recent public court record. Checked October 15, 2026. The public docket was reviewed on October 15, 2026 and showed no ruling, certification or settlement. This is not represented as a complete same-day PACER docket review.

  • Maghoney et al. v. Promotion in Motion, Inc. and Welch Foods Inc.

    Pending, as reported by a secondary tracker

    Recent secondary tracker report. Checked October 3, 2026. A current secondary tracker reports the case pending. This is not a substitute for a complete same-day PACER docket.

  • Feliciano et al. v. Promotion In Motion, Inc.

    Pending, as reported by a secondary tracker

    Recent secondary tracker report. Checked October 3, 2026. A current secondary tracker reports the case pending. This is not a substitute for a complete same-day PACER docket.

  • Ross et al. v. PIM Brands, Inc.

    Pending, as reported by a secondary tracker

    Recent secondary tracker report. Checked October 3, 2026. A current secondary tracker reports the case pending. This is not a substitute for a complete same-day PACER docket.

Public docket indexes and secondary tracker reports do not establish the contents of the complete current court docket.

Sources for this module

Settlement and claims-process review

No verified court-approved settlement identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

No verified class certification identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

No verified court-approved claim form identified in the records reviewed as of November 10, 2026.

The reviewed sources do not represent a complete same-day PACER review of every docket. A proposed class is not a certified class, and dismissal alone does not establish a settlement.

Get an email if this changes

We email when a case we track has a significant development, such as class certification or a settlement.

Separate from “Share your purchase”. Never shared with law firms. Privacy

Welch's cases by circuit

Verified Welch's cases by federal circuit. The Seventh Circuit, where Franco binds, is shown in black.

  1. Ninth Circuit3
  2. Second Circuit2
  3. Seventh Circuit1
Franco is binding precedent for federal district courts in the Seventh Circuit and persuasive authority elsewhere. It does not decide every claim or establish liability. Source: Allulose Litigation case record, verified and cross-checked cases only. Last checked November 10, 2026.
View as table
Welch's cases by circuit
GroupCases
Ninth Circuit3
Second Circuit2
Seventh Circuit1

Background reading

Source record

Primary and court-derived sources are listed first. Secondary reporting is used for discovery and cross-checking.

Show all 9 sources

Bought Welch's Fruity Bites?

Six short questions. See where your product stands first, then choose whether a law firm reviewing these claims can contact you.

Share your purchase Get updates only

About 2 minutes · No receipt needed · Sharing is your choice